NY Philharmonic – The Dullness Factor

“The New York Philharmonic has a problem, which is that it doesn’t believe it has any problems. The accountants are content; the seats are almost full. The New York Philharmonic brand is intact, even aglow. But the New York Philharmonic exists, or should exist, to reflect today’s creative musical life and to continually reinvigorate the past. On many nights, it gives perfectionist executions, pedantically ‘great’ interpretations of certifiably great works–but not performances full of the feverish urgency that comes from an encounter with mind-altering music.”

Much More Than A Student Orchestra

The Miami-based New World Symphony bills itself as America’s only orchestral academy for young musicians, and stresses education as its primary mission. But in recent years, the profile of the group as a performing ensemble has been rising, helped in part by the lack of a full-time professional orchestra in Miami. “The New World inhabits a peculiar position as an educational institution that, by virtue of the extraordinary quality of its performances, has become the area’s leading classical music organization.”

25 Years Of Mixed Reviews

Toronto’s architecturally innovative and acoustically controversial Roy Thompson Hall turns 25 this year. “With the passage of years the hall’s deficiencies came to be seen – or, rather, heard – in marked contrast with pre-construction press releases promising Torontonians not just a fine hall but, rashly, the finest concert hall in the world.” A $20 million renovation helped, but debates continue to be heard over the hall, its quality, and its evolving mission.