Has Cleveland Orchestra Got The Wrong Conductor?

Anthony Holden compares orchestras he heard at this summer’s Proms and finds the mighty Cleveland Orchestra coming up wanting. “Like a pedigree dog on an over-tight leash, this is a dazzling orchestra with an uptight conductor. Devotees of this mightiest of masses found much to disappoint, from the underwhelming Cleveland chorus to the less than inspirational conducting of Franz Welser-Most (known to our own LPO, with whom he had an unhappy six years in the 1990s, as ‘Frankly, Worse Than Most’). His orchestra is one of the world’s finest, its strings boasting as much sheen as the Berlin’s, its wind players capable of sonic miracles. So why is Welser-Most so “bloodless”?