Post-Gay? No, Two Boys Is Pre-Gay

J. Bryan Lowder: “I’m interested in how impressively and arrestingly [the new Nico Muhly opera] illuminates the psychic space where [labels like ‘gay’] honestly don’t (quite yet) apply. … It’s all the stuff that is retroactively explained by ‘gay’ once you’re out, but is something else while you still don’t quite realize that you’re in.”

The Dutch Grapple With “Black Pete”

The black-faced, red-lipped servant of Sinterklaas – often more beloved by regular folks than the goody-goody St. Nick himself, it must be said – has been the subject of controversy in the Netherlands off and on for decades. But this year, following the suggestion by a black UNESCO official that the character should be abolished, the issue has become “an existential revolt not seen in Dutch society since the murder of Pim Fortuyn.”

What Happened To Criticism (And Why It Doesn’t Work)

“It became a profession, even a guild, heavy on trade craft and jargon and dedicated to exclusion and self-protection. It became a way of credentialing an insider class and assuring its members of an income inside of the academy. As such, criticism took up a specialized vocabulary whose chief function, as I see it, was to signal loyalty to the executive board of the approved critical class.”