Is The Internet Really Helping People Govern Themselves? (Erm …)

“There is a lively debate in progress about what some call Gov 2.0. One camp sees in the Internet an unprecedented opportunity to bring back Athenian-style direct democracy.” People on the other side “worry that [the Web] creates a falsely reassuring illusion of equality, openness, universality.” And the Gov 2.0 they’ve seen so far doesn’t look so promising.

The “Expert” Problem

“The problem is not the status of the expert but its politicisation. All too often experts do not confine their involvement in public discussion to the provision of advice. Many insist that their expertise entitles them to have the last word on policy deliberation. Recent studies indicate that in public debates those whose views run counter to the sentiments of scientific experts find it difficult to voice their beliefs.”