It’s 2010 And Charles McNulty Has Just Seen ‘Cats’ For The First Time

“But how could I have missed this feline phenomenon? Me, an honest-to goodness cat-person, always bunking with a few lovable rescues and unable to resist preparing a wet-and-dry banquet for any stray sneaking into my backyard. More to point, how could I have turned a blind eye to a show that set the touristy tone for Broadway for more than a generation?”

Brantley: Those Rumors That Phantom Sequel Stinks? True.

“Of course, bad advance word on the Internet has sometimes proved false. (Ever hear of ‘Avatar’?) And I would be delighted to tell you that’s what happened here, especially since ‘Love Never Dies’ is scheduled for Broadway this fall. But how can I, when at every opportunity Mr. Lloyd Webber’s latest sets itself up to be knocked down?”